About Inside Insurance


We look to earn client’s confidence by not “selling” insurance. We know that you expect us to be a business partner that helps you manage risk through insurance solutions. We want to exceed your expectations by providing multiple solutions coupled with service you deserve. Our company is focused on a set of key principles that guide us:

  • Connector.


  • Connector.


  • Connector.



We are committed to helping you manage the risks that arise in everyday life. If the unexpected strikes, we will do everything we can to help you recover your quality of life as soon as possible. We are guided by highest standards of integrity and professionalism so you can be sure that our recommendations will help you obtain the best insurance coverage for your unique circumstances, in the right amount and at a price that fits your budget.

Our Expertise

Inside Insurance is a full-service independent agency and brokerage firm. We provide custom designed insurance packages to meet your individual, and business needs. Inside Insurance also facilitates health, financial benefits, and wealth management for individuals, foundations, not for profit organizations, and businesses. With over 50 years in business, see why thousands of clients prefer to take advantage of the inside.


As a young father in Star Valley, Wyoming, Morris Haderlie had big dreams. Providing for his family was the most important, but he also dreamed of being his own boss and creating his own leasing and financing company. He moved his eight children to Arizona, to New Mexico, and finally to Orem, Utah where the Haderlie Insurance Agency was born in 1961. With his wife at his side as his only secretary, he worked hard to make ends meet – and soon the business began to grow.

For years his sons and his wife assisted Morris in adding new and bigger accounts. In 1990, he realized that he could not keep up with the rapid growth he was experiencing. Scott Shumway, recognizing his father-in-law’s need for a partner, left his own 10-year-old agency in the state of Washington to assist in the growing Utah business. Now, with the gradual addition of Scott’s family, Haderlie Risk Service has changed its name to Shumway Insurance Group and continues to grow.

Shumway Insurance Group has employees and agents with over 100 years combined experience. Each agent has been trained for specific risk management areas. Each CSR is credentialed, and the agency is well equipped to handle all insurance needs. Through this growth, new philosophies have developed, but Morris, Scott, and their children have never lost sight of the values that earn the loyalty of their clients. Shumway Insurance Group is still the same company that Morris created over 50 years ago, with strong family values and deep community ties.

In January of 2011, Shumway Insurance Group decided it was time to grow even faster. They announced a new retail property and casualty division, Inside Insurance. Since 2011 they have experienced a steady annual growth of over 20% a year. These combined entities now have investments and premiums exceeding $200 million.

In business for over 50 years, Inside Insurance is able to provide solutions for all of your insurance, financial, and benefit needs. Our Agents, Underwriters, Financial Advisers, and Customer Service Representatives are all credentialed. Every Inside Insurance adviser has specific areas of expertise so they can truly provide each client with the “Inside” advantage.

(Products marketed, offered, or in anyway represented or produced by Inside Insurance, and affiliated companies may vary by licensing, or by state. Please contact a company representative to confirm availability in your area.)



Scott Shumway
Chairman of the Board

Jonathan Shumway

Cabe Atkinson
Executive VP

James Shumway
Executive VP

Celeste Fitzhugh
Commercial Lines Customer Service

Ariane McCabe
Accounting Manager

Rachel Rona
Personal Lines Customer Service Manager

Katie Bellon
Commercial Lines Customer Service

Drew Keddington
Underwriting Manager

Kym Wilson
Benefits Manager